Home Home / Some Thoughts on Leadership (1997)

Speech

November 29, 1997

Some Thoughts on Leadership (1997)

Shelach Jewish Unity Orthodoxy & Other Denominations The Rabbinate
View The Text

This content is currently available in its original PDF format. As we expand the library, we plan to add a text version as well.

RELATED CONTENT

Speech

Integrity or Unity: Which? (1998)

I am grateful to you for the tribute extended to me, especially since I have been associated with the Union, one way or another, for almost my entire career. And I am pleased that my working relationship with the O-U leadership, from the visionary days of Moe Feuerstein to the enormously focused and effective era of Mendy Ganchrow, has been felicitous, friendly, and fruitful. I feel even more honored by being included in the group of distinguished rabbis who are my co-honorees. As one who has been in the pulpit rabbinate for 25 years, and out of it for over 20 years, I am in a good position to evaluate the worth of the pulpit rabbis to the American Jewish Orthodox community. And I tell you, without exaggeration, that these eleven men are the unsung heroes of Torah Judaism in America. As the Passover Haggada has it, “Who knows eleven? I know eleven—eleven are the stars of the heavens.” They are truly stars, representative of the hundreds of our pulpit rabbis throughout the country who are so often taken for granted, working assiduously, usually outside the confined perimeters of the bustling centers of Jewish life and the Yeshivot with their consuming intensity. They are, in many ways, truly the sentinels of Yiddishkeit in America. I am proud that the Orthodox Union is recognizing these rabbis and the colleagues whom they represent. They, and the Orthodox Union, are worthy of our most heartfelt approbation.The Problem of UnityPermit me to share with you a problem that has been the cause of deep distress to me. We stand today at a critical juncture in the history of our people. Our generation must make a fateful decision: will we remain one people, or will we be fragmented to two or more peoples unable to marry each other and therefore permanently divided from each other?Since the beginning, it has been Torah, our ancestral faith, that has kept us as one, despite all the centrifugal forces threatening to pull us apart. With the weakening of Torah study and observance…
Jewish Unity Orthodoxy & Other Denominations

Speech

Sheep and Shepherds; Ruminations on Leadership in Jewish Thought and Practice (1993)

Let me begin by clearing up the title of this talk, "Sheep and Shepherds: Ruminations on Leadership in Jewish Thought and Practice." Sheep and shepherds, צאן ורועה, are the Biblical metaphors for followers and leaders. I prefer that particular symbol because of the relationship between sheep and lambs... And both, after all, are classified as ruminants, hence the beginning of the subtitle... Puns aside, I am concerned that in our own מחנה, especially in the ranks of the RCA as well as YU, the spurning of leadership roles has become a generational phenomenon. When I got סמיכה, leadership was something we were naturally expected to exercise; it was a self-understood element in the responsibilities that רבנות imposed upon us. Whether and to what extent my generation, and the one before mine, executed this duty, is beside the point; the fact is that we knew we were expected to be leaders and that leadership was part and parcel of the functioning Rabbinate. That does not seem to be the fact any longer. For years now, young men have been choosing education over the Rabbinate, and that is not only because of their love of Torah or the scathing criticism of the American Orthodox Rabbinate in some circles (and by people who, ironically, now regularly bemoan the decline of the Rabbinate) , but also because they fear the responsibilities of leadership—communal or halakhic—and prefer a profession which keeps them linked to Torah but limits their "leadership" to 20-30 children! The result is fewer men in the Rabbinate and, of those who do enter, hardly any assumption that a Rav must be a leader, a doer, a mover and shaker and challenger of the status quo. Such leadership is evident in some other Orthodox circles—witness the aggressive outreach programs and the en- trepreneurial enthusiasm of groups such as Lubavitch and some of the "Yeshiva" circles. I am concerned because the problem is far more than theoretical. It touches on the very destiny of our community—the community de…
Shelach Modern Orthodoxy & the Charedim The Rabbinate

Speech

The Responsibility of Leadership in the American Orthodox Community (1988)

When I was first invited to speak at this Convention, I was unsure of what topic to choose. When I asked the conveners what I should speak about, they gave me two concise answers. First, they said, "speak about 30 minutes." Second, they recommended I speak about "The Responsibility of Leadership in the American Orthodox Community." I shall cheerfully make every effort to accomodate both wise suggestions. The truth is that this theme has engaged and fascinated and worried me for a long time. And I have come to a rather surprising yet significant conclusion which can be summed up by saying that, in addition to and above all else, leadership requires the taking of risks – not only political and financial and social and psychological risks, but also moral risks.There is a remarkable statement by חז״ל which is quoted by Maimonides in his פיה"מ לאבות פ"א מ"ט, although our texts do not carry this dictum as he cites it. It reads: כל מי שהציבור ממנה אותו פרנס מלמטה נקרא רשע למעלה. "One who is appointed to a position of leadership by the community here below, is regarded as wicked up above." A similar thought occurs in the Zohar (III, p.24a). On the verse אשר נשיא יחטא, "if a prince (i.e., a king, a leader) sins," the Zohar adds two words, ודאי יחטא, "he most certainly will sin!" You cannot be a פרנס or a נשיא without being considered a רשע or a חוטא.What a strange thing to say--and what a deterrent to public service on behalf of the community! Granted that some leaders abuse their positions and that others may be neglectful of their duties, is that a reason to say that al 1 leaders are regarded by Heaven as רשעים or חוטאים, as evil or sinful? Do we not bear enough burdens, and is there not enough to discourage us without this added onus placed upon us by the Talmud, the Zohar, and the Rambam What the Rabbis meant, I believe, is this: Leadership involves making hard decisions--or better: dirty decisions, choosing between alternatives neither of which is perfect or clean or p…
Jewish Unity Orthodoxy & Other Denominations Principles of Leadership