Home Sukkot / Library / Articles / Shabbat & Holidays / Sukkot / Definitions of Judaism (1961)

Article

April 1961

Definitions of Judaism (1961)

General Jewish Thought
View The Text

This content is currently available in its original PDF format. As we expand the library, we plan to add a text version as well.

RELATED CONTENT

Article

Orthodoxy and Character (1967)

The question to which this essay is addressed – the ethical practice of committed, religious Jews – is one of the most urgent of the complex of problems which afflict Jews and Judaism in modern times. I seriously doubt whether it is within the competence of any essay to propose an adequate solution and the effective means of dealing with the issue. Nevertheless, in the hope that some insights may be gained even if by inadvertency, from this kind of impressionistic analysis, I am pleased to contribute whatever I can to the discussion. That there is a painful discrepancy between the theory and practice of Orthodox Judaism, that too many Jews who are observant of the “ritual” law are flawed ethically – needs, unfortunately, no confirmation. It is obvious to anyone who lives in the Orthodox community, and has eyes to see, that all is not well with us.However, this self-evident fact must not be exaggerated, lest we befoul the problem with cur own guilt feelings, and con-found an already complex issue with an even more complicated collective masochism. Any attempt, for instance, to read a pro-pensity for corruption into the essential character of the Jewish people, to locate the source of ethical weakness in "some basic trait" in our people, is the kind of extravagance which, in addition to revealing a racist bias, befuddles any attempt at clear under--2-standing. Further-more, it should not be blithely assumed that Orthodox Jews are any worse in their social ethics than any other Jews or any other human beings. It is possible, of course, that independent research will corroborate as an objective fact what is now merely a suspicion that observant Jews possess less integrity than others. But unless and until such "proof" is forthcoming, what is but an assumption should not be elevated to the status of a fact. My personal impression is that this is certainly not the case.Moreover, the focusing of our concerns on the social and personal dimensions of Judaism should not be …
General Jewish Thought

Assorted

Problems in Jewish Philosophy: Assignments, Reports, and Papers (1972)

All students must read N. Lamm, Faith and Doubt, chap. I and chap. III. Précis of chap. I must be submitted by midterm date, and that of chap. III by the last regular session of the semester. Reports – one report by each student, to be submitted by midterm date: a) Lev Shestov, Athens and Jerusalem; b) the behaviorism debate: B.F. Skinner, Beyond Freedom and Dignity, and Noam Chomsky, New York Review of Books, December 30, 1971; c) faith as a mitzvah in Maimonides; d) synopsis of Mortimer Adler et al., The Idea of Freedom, vol. I (Institute for Philosophical Study); e) the philosophical nature of halakhic norms – Faith and Doubt chap. IX, מפרשי המקרא על לא תסור: רש״י, רמב״ם, כלי יקר, והעמק דבר; מדרש שמואל על אבות לסוף פרק ה על המשנה הפך בה והפך בה; שו״ת עמק הלכה חלק ב סימן א; g) Kant on “character” – Critique of Pure Reason, part III, and Anthropology, part II. Research papers – examine the following to determine views on “character.” Does the thinker in question have a consistent and systematic view of character? If there is no single rule you can discern, can you determine if there are specific ethical notions or moral traits which are especially valued? Are there any problems in character, or in ethical philosophy, that the author takes up? a) Hazon Ish – there are also a number of other works that have recently appeared on the Hazon Ish; b) R. Shneur Zalman of Ladi – the secondary sources will guide you to the primary sources. See Teitlbaum (vol. II): החזון איש על עניני אמונה (a Chabad publication), pp. 113–122, and the growing literature of the movement; c) Saadia Gaon – analyze carefully part X, and consult the various histories of Jewish philosophy for their observations; d) R. Abraham Maimonides – check through ספר המפסיק לעובד ה; e) Rav Kook – the recently published אורות ה׳, chap. II and chap. III; f) R. Israel Salanter – use Katz as your guide both to sources and for formulation; g) R. Hayyim of Volozhin – read through his נפש החיים (commentary on “ה׳”)…
General Jewish Thought

Article

Reflexions sur l'Art et la Judaisme (1951)

Le Flambeaue, dixie me anniversaire. Table des Matieres: Editorial, par le Redacteur _______________________________________________5, Renan, etait-il Judeophobe ? Par Maurice Lamin_______________________________________________6, Napoleon et le Sanhedrin, par Joseph Erushalmy_______________________________________________10, L’Ecolc Rabbinique de France, par Salomon J. Kohn_______________________________________________12, Esquisse de Jacques Halevy, par Gilbert S. Rosenthal_______________________________________________14, Variations sur un theme en S mineur, par F. Weindling --------------------- 15, Les influences bibliques sur Emile Durkhcim, par S. Wexler----------------- 16, Marcel Proust nous depcint une famille juivc, par T. Kronengold ----------- 19, Pocmc, par Jules Ehrman --------------------------------------------------- 24, Bernard Lazarc — Une biographic, par Philip Silverstein ------------------- 24, — Le Paria dans Le Fumier de Job, par Arthur Abramson ______ 26, Bibliographic de quelques oeuvres franchises traduites cn hebreu, par Jack. Adelman 28./Le Juif moderne d’apres "Israel” de Henry Bernstein, par Charles Spirit --- 30/Reflexions sur 1’Art et le Judaisme, par Norman Lamm ---------------------- 36le flambeau, la publication franfaise de, YESHIVA UNIVERSITY, CONSEILLER, Profcsscur Sidney D. BRAUN, REDACTEUR EN CHEF, Jules EHRMAN, REDACTEUR ASSOC1EJack ADELMAN, Washington Heights, New York 33, N. Y.sun adultere, il est chatie par son fils et fi- nalement vaincu, demeurant seul comme son peuple. Cependant, arriviste qu’il est, il continucra probablemcnt a avoir ses sue- ses, alors que le fils qu’il admirait meme en champion antisemite est une figure tragi- que. Nous rejetons naturellement son anti- semitisme aussi grossier que celui des autres gentlemen s’adonnant a ce jeu. Mais s’il y a de la verite dans la remarque de Gutlieb que "pour persuader a 38 millions de chre'.icns que la presence, parmi eux, de 60,000 juifs constituait un peril nati…
General Jewish Thought