Home Home / Letter to Dayan Ehrentreu about Attendi…

Correspondence

Nov. 18, 2003

Letter to Dayan Ehrentreu about Attending Limmud Conference (2003)

Orthodoxy & Other Denominations
View The Text

This content is currently available in its original PDF format. As we expand the library, we plan to add a text version as well.

RELATED CONTENT

Correspondence

Letter to Moses Feuerstein about Israel's Reform Movement (1963)

Dear Moe: I know how busy you are, especially with all the recent unfortunate developments in your family. Nevertheless, I am sending you enclosed the most recent copy of the CCAR Journal, and suggest that you read carefully the very first article on Reform Judaism in Israel. Especially notice the underlined parts. I think it is important for someone in your position to be aware of the kind of secret activity currently being conducted by the reformed group. Fondest regards.Cordially yours,RABBI NORMAN LAMMNLsf
Orthodoxy & Other Denominations

Correspondence

Letter from the "Torah Action Committee" Threatening R. Lamm about Position on Interdenominational Dialogue (1966)

Rabbi Norman Lamm... We were shocked to read that you too are throwing overboard tradition and loyalty to the Gedolim... and have accepted to join a Reform and Conservative rabbi... as guest of honor for the Hadoar Dinner... We shall wait 10 days... until Dec. 8th. If no retraction in paper... we shall appeal to leaders of The Jewish Center to dismiss you because of your dissent and abrogation of Torah authority. Please remove this Chilul Hashem at once. Have mercy on Torah and your Roshei Hayeshiva. Torah Action Committee – YU Branch
Orthodoxy & Other Denominations

Correspondence

Letter to R. Weingarten about the Future of the Reform Movement (1997)

Dear Uzi: I just returned from my Israel-Prague trip and haven’t yet had time to unpack and go through my accumulated mail and calls, but I did want to respond to your somewhat anguished query about my interviews with Yom Hashishi and Makor Rishon. I did not see the printed results of the interviews, but – yes – I did and do feel that Reform has no future. I do not say this with any degree of satisfaction or triumphalism, certainly not with Schadenfreude. Indeed, it is tragic to even contemplate where Reform (and, for that matter, most of the American–Jewish community) is going. My prediction is based upon a cold (very cold!) analysis of the demographic data and the simple extrapolations, granted, of course, that no major societal or cultural convulsions will occur. Walk into any Reform Temple in this country and keep both your eyes and ears open and you will sense the tragic mass movement, lemming-like, into obscurity. Of course, if you’re willing to accept patrilinealism and easy “conversions” and “inclusivism” (which includes non-Jewish spouses officiating at various “rituals” in the “service”), then the future shines bright. But are you willing to make that assumption? Are you ready to have your humanism (in the best sense), your compassion, and Ahavat Yisrael so overwhelm your primary sense data and perception of objective facts that you are ready to concede that they are viable for the next few generations as a Jewish community? I am not ready to do that, because such transcendental ignorance does not contribute to healthy and effective communal planning. I repeat that we are facing a tragedy, and I am not in the business of assigning blame – there is enough to go around to all concerned. But this is what I foresee, what I fear, what I think must be said if we are to find or create some harbor for the gathering storm. For me to do otherwise is to submit to cultural correctness, which is every bit as dangerous as political correctness. So, Uzi, that’s where I…
Orthodoxy & Other Denominations