Home Letter from Leo Landman about Winning Harav Maimon Award / Letter from Leo Landman about Winning Harav Maimon Award / בשלח (1952)

Note

February 9, 1952

בשלח (1952)

Beshalach
View Original
View Text View Original

[See תורה שלמה, on מאמר that שפחה ראתה על הים מה שיחזקאל הנביא לא ראה מימיו, different version from מכילתא: שפחה ראתה על הים מה שלא ראו ישע' וירמי' ויחזקאל וכל הנביאים] 1. Analysis of song of Moses shows it isn't so stock full of holiness after all. Except for verse or two, most of it is war-song – victory over Pharoh and Egyptians. סוסו ורוכבו רמה בים etc. – and any people will sing of its victory – no mention of liberty, sanctity of freedom. 2. Rabbis already voiced protest – אמר הקב"ה למלאכי השרת: מעשי ידי טובעין בים ואתם אומרים שירה? – also, on פסח-סדר, co

RELATED CONTENT

Synagogue Sermon

Eternity for a Song (1963)

Judaism places great importance on the idea of shirah, song, the theme of this special Sabbath which is suggested in our Torah reading of the shirat ha-yam, the song of triumph sung by Moses and the Children of Israel at the shores of the Red Sea. One of the indications of the significance the Jewish Tradition attaches to shirah is the statement by the Rabbis deriving the doctrine of resurrection and eternal life from an analysis of the second word of the song. Az yashir Mosheh u-vnei Yisrael, “then Moses and the Children of Israel sang”- the Hebrew, however, uses the future: yashir, will sing, not shar, sang. Mi-kan li-tehiat ha-metim min ha-torah, thus we learn from the Bible, say the Rabbis, the principle of the resurrection of the dead – for it means that in the days of resurrection Moses and the Children of Israel will again sing this song. But the Sages meant more than to prove a religious doctrine by taking a poetic form literally. They meant, in a large sense, that shirah contains in it the seeds of tehiat ha-metim. They meant that you can find something of eternity in this song. If you know the secret, the inner meaning of shirah, then you can get eternity for a song.And what is that secret? Why, indeed, is shirah accorded such a place of honor in the Jewish Tradition? How can you win eternity for a song?The answer cannot be merely the esthetic quality of shirah, for other peoples speaking in other tongues produced poetry and music equal to and perhaps superior to that of Israel. The significance of shirah lies not in the senses but in the spirit, not in the art but in the heart, not in the sound but in the vision. Shirah is the expression of insight. It reveals an added dimension of personality: an awareness of hidden truths, a sensitivity to mysteries usually veiled and obscure in the normal course of mundane, prosaic life. It is the ability to perceive what is beyond the apparent, the capacity to see the world right-side-up even if it is, as it usually …
Beshalach General Jewish Thought

Synagogue Sermon

Nachas (1962)

Our Sages relate a most interesting incident concerning Rabbi Judah the Prince, the redactor of the Mishnah, affectionately known as Rebbe. One day, we are told, Rebbe hayah yoshev ve’doresh – Rabbi Judah was preaching to his congregation. Suddenly he was faced by a distressing problem, one that has challenged generations of public speakers. Nitnamnem ha-tzibbur, his audience began to fall asleep. This was a bad situation; and so, moved by a speaker’s instinct, bikesh Rebbe l’oreran, Rabbi Judah attempted to wake them up. But how is that done? Some speakers turn on the volume higher, relying more upon decibels than upon content in order to stimulate interest. Others use a variety of techniques. But not so Rebbe; instead, he aroused his listeners by making the following alarming statement: yaldah ishah be’Mitzrayim shishim ribbo be’keres achat. “There was a woman in Egypt who gave birth to 600,000 children all at once.” It is meticulously recorded by the Rabbis that at least one of his listeners, Ishmael the son of Rabbi Yose by name, was jolted out of his slumber by this piece of intelligence. What, he inquired, can you possibly mean? And Rabbi answered: zu Yocheved she’yaldah at Mosheh she’shakul ke’negged shishim ribbo shel Yisrael – I refer to Yocheved who gave birth to Moses, a man who was equated in value to the 600,000 children of Israel who lived at that time.This is indeed sensational news. It is quite unusual for mother to be blessed with a son who can lead, inspire, and teach a whole people. It is startling news that parents are privileged to have, as a child, a Moses. Not everyone has such good fortune. Nevertheless, every parent dreams of deriving some form of nachas from children. Every father and every mother wants to have at least an inkling of the kind of happiness, satisfaction, pleasure, pride, and fulfillment of dreams, that Amram and Yocheved derived from there Moses. Often we ask: how does one do it? What must we do to deserve such nachas? How …
Beshalach General Jewish Thought Birth & Circumcision

Synagogue Sermon

The Meaning of Faith (1953)

“Faith” as a subject for a sermon by a Rabbi seems so appropriate and so to-be-expected, that it is almost an invitation to the congregation to doze off into a gentle Sabbath nap. And yet it is a topic which is rarely discussed from a traditional Jewish pulpit. It is rarely mentioned because it is taken for granted that those who do come to synagogue already have faith. It is an assumption which is, I believe, most correct. But the fact remains that Faith is a very hazy concept, and that its causes and effects are not always understood. I believe this sufficient reason, therefore, to invite you with me in an exploration of the Jewish meaning of Faith. The first thing to be said about Faith is that it makes life liveable. Without Faith in G-d, life is neither intelligible nor worth enduring. Even the world’s greatest skeptics maintain that you have got to believe in something. Bertrand Russell that famous philosopher and brilliant mathematician whom we might well dub the high-priest of all atheists, writes, “To live a human life, man must have grounding in something, in some sense outside of human life… in some end which is impersonal and above mankind such as G-d or Truth or Beauty.” Life without Faith is a dull, mechanical, meaningless routine. With it, life begins to take on meaning.Our Rabbis seem to make this point in their comments on this week’s Bible portion. The children of Israel began their long trek out of Egypt and Pharaoh’s legions began to give chase. They arrived at the banks of the Red Sea which G-d, in a miraculous act of deliverance, split in two allowing the Jews to walk across its dry banks. When they finished crossing the Red Sea, the sea rushed back, drowning the Egyptians, who were pursuing them through the divided waters, and the Jews realized that they had been helped on the first leg of their journey to freedom. At that moment, the Bible relates, vayiru ha’am es HaShem va’yaaminu ba’Shem uve’Moshe avdo, “they feared the Lord and they belie…
Beshalach Faith